MENTOR

is...

Learning Awareness
Finding Connection

 
Healing & Empowering Us
Our Horses & Our World

Understanding Horse Movement Study Guide

Category: Learning Feel through Observation / Learning Feel With Digital Imagery

Understanding Horse Movement Study Guide

Understanding Movement: A Study Guide

Questions to Think About/Help Finding New Questions So You Can Find New Answers

  1. What is a primary difference between watching horses before the age of technology and watching them today via video? 
  2. How does the author suggest that the inaccurate artistic depictions of horse movement from before cameras were developed might relate to how artists felt about the horses? (2-3 sentences)
  3. What does the author mean by the statement, "We have learned to quantify above experiencing"? 
  4. The author discusses riders today having "checklists." What are these checklists used for? 
  5. Why does the author believe that despite having access to vastly more information and visual resources, modern riders may not be better at seeing how well a horse is doing compared to past riders? 
  6. What does the author identify as "what we are missing" when watching videos and pictures of horses today? 
  7. According to the author, what is the focus of "truly extraordinary" riders compared to "more limited" riders? 
  8. What two distinct ways of learning about the relationship between horse and rider are presented by the author? 
  9. Why does the author suggest that your inability to connect to a horse in a video might be related to the quality of the movement being shown? 
  10. What type of imagery does the author recommend starting with when trying to learn to feel what the horse is feeling? 

Answer Key

  1. Before technology, watching a horse was a live experience where riders could feel the horse's energy. Today, watching videos means the experience is digital, lacking the real energy of the horse and rider.
  2. The author suggests that because artists before cameras couldn't accurately follow horse movement, they drew what they felt about the horses instead of what was true in terms of physical mechanics.
  3. This means that modern riders prioritize analyzing and cataloging information (quantifying) based on checklists and facts over directly experiencing and feeling the connection with the horse or the movement itself.
  4. These checklists are used by modern riders to assess and judge the horse's movement or physical attributes against a list of criteria they have learned, effectively "ticking off boxes" based on facts and figures.
  5. The author suggests this is because knowing more facts and figures doesn't necessarily translate into the ability to truly see or feel what is happening with the horse, as modern riders prioritize quantifying over experiencing.
  6. According to the author, what we are missing is the ability to feel what the horse is feeling and to connect heart-to-heart, as this energy and connection are lost when the experience is digital.
  7. Truly extraordinary riders focus on feeling what is inside the horse, while more limited riders worry about what they can make the horse feel or what they can do to the horse's body.
  8. The two ways are learning by checking off boxes based on facts and information, and learning by feeling and connecting with the horse.
  9. The author suggests that if the horse in the video is moving in an unhealthy or incorrect way, a rider might instinctively disconnect because the movement is so wrong.
  10. The author recommends starting with healthy imagery, specifically horses playing, without riders or equipment, and horses that have never been ridden, as these are often the best to try and connect to.

Essay Format Questions

  1. Discuss the author's central argument regarding the perceived decline in riding ability despite the increased availability of information and technology. What reasons does the author provide for this apparent paradox?
  2. Compare and contrast the two methods of learning about horses and riding presented by the author: "ticking off boxes" and "learning to feel." How does the author suggest these two approaches differ in terms of the parts of the brain involved and their ultimate outcome for the rider?
  3. Analyze the author's critique of relying heavily on quantitative analysis and checklists in assessing horse movement. What are the potential drawbacks and limitations of this approach according to the text?
  4. Explain the significance of "feeling what the horse is feeling" as described by the author. Why is this ability considered crucial for truly extraordinary riders, and what challenges does the author identify in developing this skill when using digital media?
  5. Evaluate the author's perspective on the use of video and digital assets in learning about horse movement. While acknowledging the "treasure trove" of resources, what is the primary concern raised about how these resources are currently being utilized, and what alternative approach is suggested?

Glossary of Key Terms

  • Quantify: To express or measure something as a quantity or amount. In the context of the text, it refers to analyzing and assessing horse movement using facts, figures, and specific criteria.
  • Experiencing: The process of encountering or undergoing something. In the text, it contrasts with quantifying and refers to directly feeling the energy and connection with the horse.
  • Ticking off boxes: A metaphor used to describe the process of assessing horse movement or physical attributes against a predefined list of criteria, essentially checking if specific elements are present or correct.
  • Feeling (in the context of the text): The ability to sense, perceive, and connect with the internal state, energy, and sensations of the horse, often described as a heart-to-heart connection.
  • On the forehand: A term used to describe a horse that is carrying more weight on its front legs, sometimes indicative of imbalance or poor collection.
  • Behind the vertical: Describes the position of a horse's head and neck where the nose is behind the vertical line from the poll, potentially causing stress and restricting the airway.
  • Parotid gland: A large salivary gland located near the base of the ear in horses. Pressure on this gland can occur with certain head and neck positions.
  • Airtime (in trot): The moment in the trot when all four of the horse's feet are off the ground simultaneously. A lack of airtime can indicate a restricted or incorrect gait.
  • High-quality fidelity: Refers to the degree to which a digital representation accurately reproduces the original, in this case, video or imagery that clearly and accurately depicts the horse's movement.
  • Healthy movement: Refers to movement that is biomechanically sound, balanced, and free from tension or restriction, indicative of a horse that is physically and mentally comfortable and performing correctly.